Contributed by Donata Mary Rodrigues, Swapnil S Barai, and Sasikumar Eswaramurthy, Tamil Nadu Urban Sanitation Support ProgrammeDownload story
Community and Public Toilets (CT/PTs) play an essential role in the provision of safe sanitation services. The urban poor and commuters in transit are largely dependent on CT/PTs. Though a basic necessity, most CT/PTs across cities and towns in India are poorly maintained. Instances of users misusing the toilets for other activities continues to be a concern. Improper user behaviour is the primary reason for the poor condition of these facilities.
Creating a strong Operation and Maintenance (O&M) model is key to improving this situation. With the aim of helping the Greater Chennai Corporation (GCC) to identify effective O&M models, the Indian Institute for Human Settlements (IIHS)-led Tamil Nadu Urban Sanitation Support Programme (TNUSSP) is conducting a pilot study at CT/PTs across 11 locations.
The pilot study also explores how CT/PTs can become further accessible and gender inclusive. TNUSSP has designed Behavioural Change Communication campaigns to address CTPT users’ behaviours. In the six months since the pilot programme’s introduction, there has been an increase in users across toilets. Presently, three O&M management models are being piloted: private, self-help group and individual entrepreneurs.
Community and Public Toilets (CT/PTs) play an essential role in the provision of safe sanitation services. The users dependent on them comprise urban poor communities, occasional users and users in transit. Toilets are a basic necessity, but more often than not, poor public and community toilet services discourage people from using them. An unhygienic toilet is also a breeding ground for diseases and is an indication of the inadequacies of urban sanitation services in India. An efficient community and public toilet management are especially crucial for cities with large populations.
A city like Chennai has 800+ public convenience facilities, directly or indirectly managed by the Greater Chennai Corporation (GCC). The Government of Tamil Nadu (GoTN) would like to provide safe and hygienic public conveniences to all citizens free of cost. Although there is an increasing demand for improved service provision, GoTN and Urban Local Bodies face two key challenges in managing CT/PTs – increasing service coverage while at the same time improving services and sustenance of operations, including financing operations.
Tamil Nadu Urban Sanitation Support Programme (TNUSSP) has been working with the GCC on demonstrating service models for O&M of CT/PTs. In January 2022, a study was conducted in 64 community toilets in zones 5,6,7,9,13 and 14 of the city to understand the current infrastructural status of conveniences along with their O&M models. Based on the findings, 11 facilities were shortlisted for intervention in zones 13 and 14. The facilities were selected based on the location of toilets (main road, inner roads, within a community), types of users, footfall pattern and arrangements for waste disposal. As refurbishment is the key to improved service provision, TNUSSP shared the standards for an inclusive CT/PT with GCC and based on this, the toilets were refurbished for lighting, ventilation, accessibility for senior citizens and differently abled citizens, installation of sanitary napkin vending machines, feedback instruments, CCTV cameras, mirrors, soap trays and towel rods in all toilet complexes. Figure 2 and 3 shows the toilets before-and-after refurbishment.
In June 2022, TNUSSP piloted three types of O&M models which differ by the type of service provider, while paving the way for revenue potentials at these facilities, which do not charge any user fee:
The allocation of toilet facilities to the service providers was determined by parameters such as visibility, advertisement potential, community users, footfall, and underground sewerage scheme /on-site sanitation system connection. The facility management company was selected by evaluation of technical and financial bids. This move aims to identify effective and efficient O&M models for the CT/PTs in the GCC area to ensure the availability of safe and hygienic sanitation facilities for the users.
The demonstration ensures compliance with all applicable laws and maintains the hygiene standards at the designated facility to improve its usage by the community and public. The scope of the demonstration (Figure 4) covers the identification of service delivery models and the assessment of these models by implementing and monitoring them in eleven CT/PTs in a time span of two years. In addition, the demonstration also covers the implementation of innovative on-site sanitation systems.
Regular training of staff on maintenance of the toilets and behaviour change communication to the users on the proper use of toilets are a part of the venture, along with ensuring adequate water availability and infrastructural upkeep at these facilities for the safety and security of its users.
Five of the toilets taken up for demonstration are dependent on on-site sanitation. As the usage of toilets has increased, the frequency of desludging has also increased. Therefore, one PT (Kottivakkam) and one CT (Anna Nedunsalai) have been selected for piloting the multi-unit reinvented toilet (MURT) technology. The MURT is a transformative technology that will destroy all pathogens on-site, recover valuable resources and operate without sewer connections. It is proposed to use the treated water for flushing, cleaning and gardening purposes. The staffing at the toilet undertaken by different service providers is as per the guidelines of the Central Public Health & Environmental Engineering Organisation (CPHEEO). The TNUSSP team conducts overall supervision. Standard reporting formats have been developed for monitoring user count, inventory, expenses, repair and maintenance, de-sludging and grievance resolution. Flow meters have been installed to monitor water consumption. Service providers adhere to the service level agreements measured through a list of indicators using KoboCollect (an open-source Android app for collecting survey data).
The key lessons from this intervention are:
About the Author
Donata Mary Rodrigues is a Senior Consultant – Practice at IIHS. She has worked on projects empowering the marginalized sections of society for over two decades. Donata works in the gender and social inclusion team at TNUSSP. She also manages the demonstration of service provision models in public and community toilets in Chennai.
Swapnil S Barai is a qualified social development sector professional with over 15 years of experience in multiple domains and has worked in areas such as development project management, research, monitoring & evaluation, social enterprise development, resettlement and rehabilitation, community health, livelihoods, agriculture, philanthropy and fundraising. He has a bachelor’s degree in social work from the Tata Institute of Social Sciences (TISS) and is currently pursuing a PhD in economics.
Sasikumar Eswaramurthy is a Senior Consultant – Practice at IIHS. He has more than 10 years of work experience in the water–sanitation sector and has been working as a specialist in the engineering, planning and implementation support component for the TNUSSP Project. He has been involved in the review of detailed project reports for the Faecal Sludge Treatment Plant in Trichy City Corporation and Periyanaickenpalayam in Coimbatore, and its construction, execution and implementation. Other areas of focus include the study of stormwater drain pollution and the assessment of sewage and fecal sludge treatment.
About the Organisation
Since 2016, the Tamil Nadu Urban Sanitation Support Programme, a consortium led by the Indian Institute for Human Settlements, has been proactively supporting the Government of Tamil Nadu in making improvements along the entire urban sanitation chain in cities. We work towards strengthening septage management as an economical and sustainable complement to network-based sewerage systems and aim to scale Faecal Sludge Management across 649 towns in the state, covering a total urban population of 30 million.